Googling "hp psc1200 mac os x print black white" produced unsatisfactory results IMHO. This post aims to correct this:
System Preferences > Print & Scan > Options & Supplies > Driver > Installed Print Cartridge > Black
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/477a9/477a988d2b7104bad141bf6834d90b3dc1382526" alt=""
</not_technically_interesting>
<!-- hopefully future posts will be technically_interesting -->